Ask Audrey Ask Audrey
Archived

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

"There’s little sense of wonder or magic"

Audrey review: Some sugary highs but Willy not wonky enough to sustain interest.

Text size
Text size
Add to favourites

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

Date: 14 Jan 2019

Enter a world of pure imagination, where golden tickets, a lifetime supply of sweets and whizzing Great Glass Elevators aren’t the stuff of dreams.

This is the wonder of Roald Dahl’s wickedly delightful 1964 novel, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory­, a rags-to-riches tale wrapped up in so much confectionary goodness, it has melted kids and adults’ hearts and stuck with them over decades, like sticky lollies in pockets.

And after a delectable film adaptation (Gene Wilder’s Willy Wonka becoming iconic in his own right), it’s hard not to crave another version of this story.

But this newly conjured-up musical proves imagination is still key to the weird and wonderful world of Willy Wonka. Without that much-needed magic, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is a flat dessert, one that has some but not all of the right ingredients required for the sugar high we desire (and deserve).

Panned first in London for its plain score and slow-moving book (David Greig) before being completely reworked with new director Jack O’Brien for Broadway, this Australian premiere hasn’t exactly solved the problems of its previous productions.

O’Brien also helms this Australian show. He’s retooled it slightly, inserting nudge-and-wink historical Australian references to the Eureka Stockade and Ned Kelly, and even letting the twang of the local Australian accent ring freely on stage.

The reason for these changes isn’t clear, especially when the musical loses much of its colour and original wackiness in the process. Sketching out the narrative in the broadest of strokes, Charlie Bucket (played on opening night by a sweet, wide-eyed Ryan Yeates) lives in a house of scrap-heaps, with his bed-ridden grandparents (including Grandpa Joe, a twinkly-eyed, charming Tony Sheldon) and mother (a criminally under-used but endearing Lucy Maunder).

When Charlie finds one of five Golden Tickets secreted in Willy Wonka’s signature confectionary line, he’s granted all-areas access into the workings of the mysterious Wonka Chocolate Factory.

He’s joined by modern revisions of four nasty children, all played here by adults: Bulgarian sausage-devouring Augustus Gloop (Jake Fehily); screaming Russian ballet brat Veruca Salt (Karina Russell); social media diva Violet Beuregard (Monette McKay), and gaming-addict Mike Teavee (Harrison Riley).

It takes the children a while to get fully stuck in the world of chocolate fantasy. The musical’s structure meanders in a long Act One introduction of tiring breaking-news vignettes, sung through as a pastiche of forgettable musical tunes from Marc Shaiman and lyricist Scott Wittman (the Broadway duo behind Hairspray and most recently Mary Poppins Returns).

An emphasis on the Candyman character (who is actually Wonka disguised) as an amusing audience in-joke wears out pretty quickly. It’s more a relief, than a true surprise when Wonka (American import Paul Slade Smith) finally appears with the catchiest of choruses during the Act One closer, “It Must Be Believed to Be Seen”.

Unfortunately, our eyes aren’t treated to much candied euphoria when it’s time to enter the Factory, although the LED video projection does try awfully hard to impress (scenic design from Mark Thompson and video design by Jeff Sugg).

Cheesy PowerPoint transitions and montage animations hang tackily as graphic backdrops with minimal physically-crafted sets. It can’t even save “Pure Imagination” – a song that’s about defying explanation, which is then ironically countered by a chocolate waterfall made out of plain brown cloth. There’s little sense of wonder or magic in these vast rooms and the gimmicky inventions that should make Wonka’s humble abode so extraordinary.

There’s also little shade to the musical, which makes it an easy watch but not necessarily a consistently entertaining one. A few show-stopping numbers are exceptions. In one, the Oompa Loompas show off in a captivating puppetry dance break. In another, giant squirrels engage in an absurdly twisted ballet sequence with Veruca Salt. Otherwise, the macabre, whimsical humour of Dahl’s book is barely present, and not even children facing direly ambiguous ends is enough to inject that dark undertone into the story.

Even Slade Smith’s portrayal of Wonka is more poised and less wonky than his predecessors, and you can’t help but feel he’s playing it safe.

Then again, risk-taking isn’t exactly on this production’s radar. It’s more harmless fun than anything, so it’s hard not to be swept up in its waffling ideas of edible dreams or dote on the joyful innocence of young Charlie. But be prepared to bring your own imagination to the show – or a box of chocolates – to better satisfy that sugar craving.

Content
Murder on the Wireless
Add to favourites
ArchivedEnsemble Theatre, Kirribilli, Sydney 7 Jun - 13 Jul 2019

Murder on the Wireless

Audrey review: A genial but shallow tribute to the era of the wireless serial transports its audience to a radio studio, circa 1959.

Mamma Mia!
Add to favourites
ArchivedRiverside Theatres, Parramatta, Sydney 2 - 17 Aug 2019

Mamma Mia!

Abba’s glam pop hits propel the story of 20-year-old Sophie’s attempt to discover the identity of her father on the eve of her wedding.

Diplomacy
Add to favourites
ArchivedThe Joan, Penrith, Sydney 3 - 3 Aug 2019

Diplomacy

Audrey review: Master craftsmen John Bell and John Gaden add weight to Cyril Gely's light-touch World War II thriller.

See More

More to see

View All
Once
Add to favourites
ArchivedEternity Playhouse, Darlinghurst, Sydney 30 Jul - 4 Aug 2019

Once

Featuring the music and lyrics of Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová, this is the hit musical adaptation of John Carney's acclaimed film.

A View from the Bridge
Add to favourites
ArchivedIPAC, Wollongong, NSW 28 - 31 Aug 2019

A View from the Bridge

Arthur Miller’s searing drama cuts deeply in this gripping, award-winning independent production first seen at the Old Fitzroy Theatre in 2017.

City of Gold
Add to favourites
ArchivedGriffin Theatre, Kings Cross, Sydney 26 Jul - 31 Aug 2019

City of Gold

Meyne Wyatt's debut play focuses on a young Indigenous actor struggling with being typecast in an industry with its own ideas of authenticity.

Life of Galileo
Add to favourites
ArchivedBelvoir, Surry Hills, Sydney 3 Aug - 15 Sep 2019

Life of Galileo

Colin Friels stars in Brecht’s classic play of individual liberty and political suppression.

Top